40 Years of Church Trends: Part 3

These posts are based on an article by Philip Jenkins “12 Trends That Shaped U.S. Religion Since the ’70s.” Read the full article and then return here for the Church of Christ and my personal slant.

7. Global awareness.

Since the end of WWII, the American church, including the Churches of Christ, initiated a new age of foreign missions. The invention of commercial air travel and the global influence of the United States made travel cheaper and faster and opened doors to American missionaries across the globe. I can’t verify the numbers, but I suspect there are more Church of Christ members outside the US than inside today.

More recently, the influence of Americanism has declined but travel and communication have become easier and cheaper. On the other hand, major mission points are becoming more hostile to American missionaries, especially in Russia and India.

The fall of the Iron Curtain has opened up other areas that were once very difficult to get to. But Islamic extremism makes mission work life threatening in some areas.

Meanwhile, the universities are studying mission efforts to develop best practices to give the missionaries a better chance at being effective, and these studies are revolutionizing how mission work is done in many areas.

And just as much of the world is becoming anti-American, the mission work of prior generations has brought about a generation of native missionaries, so that mission work is no longer necessarily Americans teaching non-Americans. Some churches planted in the 1950s have had multiple generations of their own elders and preachers and are sending out their own missionaries.

On the other hand, American support for foreign missionaries is being severely undercut by a preference for short-term missions by teenagers and college students, often designed primarily with the Americans in mind. That is, the “mission” is considered successful if the Americans learn about foreign poverty and gain a new appreciation for their standard of living, even if no converts are made and little good is done for the people in the nation visited. (This is, of course, not always true.)

8. The vanishing mainline.

The old European denominations are in precipitous decline. Their members seem to largely be transferring to more conservative churches, typically non-denominational community churches. Some have congregations that are as conservative as any evangelical church, but the overall trend is theologically liberal (even denying the resurrection), downward, and continuing so.

However, Christianity as a whole is holding its own in the US, with community and Pentecostal churches especially enjoying rapid growth.

9. The return of tradition.

Traditional and conservative religious forms have grown massively, and in many cases became the mainstream. This is true of evangelical and charismatic Christians, and of Orthodox and ultra-Orthodox Jews. In both cases, demography accounts for part of the story, but not all.

Orthodoxy is becoming less Greek Orthodox or Russian Orthodox and more generic or even American Orthodox and so is less tied to immigrant communities. As a result, the Orthodox are finding receptive believers outside their historic immigrant constituencies. Many believers enjoy feeling connected with ancient practices. For similar reasons, many evangelical Protestants are joining conservative Anglican/Episcopalian churches.

“High church” ritual is gaining ground, but not universally. The low-church Pentecostals and evangelicals are enjoying growth as well. The best conclusion is that even though believers increasingly care little about denominational affiliation, different people find different expressions of Christianity preferable. The overall trend is that people have differing needs and tastes, and one size does not fit all. And those who join, say, an Orthodox church likely do not consider the Orthodox as the only saved believers. To them, it’s simply one style of worship among many that God approves. We are united by faith in Jesus, not a common worship style or creedbook.

10. The politics of God.

In the mid-1970s, cross-faith alliances like the Moral Majority and the Religious Right were barely imaginable, but both enjoyed huge power in their day. Arguably, the heyday of conservative religious politics has passed, but on specific issues, it might easily return.

One positive consequence of the “culture wars” has been a radical change in interdenominational attitudes, especially when set against long American precedent.

From the 1970s, conservative Protestants, Catholics, Mormons and Jews found they had common cause on many basic political issues, and that de facto alliance promoted the ongoing quest for cultural and theological common ground.

I did not know that. I did know that a few years ago, many Alabama churches crossed denominational lines to defeat a lottery proposal as taking unfair advantage of the poor. It was unprecedented in this state, but led to no further cooperative efforts that I’ve seen. Old habits are hard to break.

The involvement of the Alabama churches in politics has largely been a net negative, associating white churches with the Republican Party and black churches with the Democratic Party, and neither group making the least effort to find common ground, even on matters they agree on. Each group serves its political masters in search of power. That is, given a choice between biblical truth and supporting the party platform, both groups will support the party platform because a failure to do so means risking the loss of political power. (And Jesus is all about worldly power, right? </sarcasm font>)

11. The age of the megachurch.

A “megachurch” is a church of 2,000 or more members. And there are more megachurches every year. Despite criticisms of particular congregations, on the whole, megachurches measure as well as smaller churches, if not better, in terms of how effectively they disciple their members and evangelize the lost.

And in the age of superstores in a highly capitalistic country, many people like the advantages of a large church — the higher quality of worship music, excellent sermons, well-run small groups, etc. And most megachurches aren’t shy about requiring members to volunteer and be active. In fact, in some studies, megachurches do better than smaller churches in terms of members who volunteer for active participation in the work of the congregation.

They’re not for everyone, but much of the growth of Christianity in the US is being generated by megachurches — and much of that growth is evangelistic growth.

Again, there are plenty of big churches that can be fairly criticized for many things — which is also true of smaller churches. But as a whole, they stand up well to scrutiny. In fact, they are beginning to replace denominations as drivers of innovation and programming. Many congregations have been more influenced by Saddleback or Willow Creek than their entire denominational structure. For example, Saddleback created the Celebrate Recovery ministry that has been adopted by countless congregations across the country. I know of no similar ministry that came from a traditional denominational structure.

12. Language.

So much of today’s familiar church-speak would need a lot of explanation to our visitor from the past. Look at a typical mission statement or bulletin, and see how many words or phrases might fall into that category. Inclusiveness, yes – but what else?

Posted in Uncategorized | 6 Comments

N. T. Wright’s The Day the Revolution Began, Romans Reconsidered, Part 66D (Atonement Theories)

dayrevolutionbegan

N. T. “Tom” Wright has just released another paradigm-shifting book suggesting a new, more scriptural way of understanding the atonement, The Day the Revolution Began: Reconsidering the Meaning of Jesus’s Crucifixion. Wright delves deeply into how the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus accomplish our salvation.

A Note on “Sin Offering”

The translators disagree as to whether “sin” in Rom 8:3 is a reference simply to sin or to the sin offering of Leviticus. The key text in the Greek is —

(Rom. 8:3 BGT) περὶ ἁμαρτίας (peri hamartias, literally, concerning sin)

“Sin offering” first appears in the Bible in Lev 4:3,

(Lev. 4:3 NET) “‘If the high priest sins so that the people are guilty, on account of the sin he has committed he must present a flawless young bull to the LORD for a sin offering.”

Continue reading

Posted in Atonement, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, Romans, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

40 Years of Church Trends: Part 2

These posts are based on an article by Philip Jenkins “12 Trends That Shaped U.S. Religion Since the ’70s.” Read the full article and then return here for the Church of Christ and my personal slant.

3. Shifts in family structure.

I graduated high school in 1972. My church of 200 or so members had exactly one divorced couple. None of my friends were from families where the spouses were divorced. The single-parent kids I grew up had lost a parent to death, not divorce.

Now, it’s hard to find a child with an intact nuclear family. Families without divorces are rare — the sort of thing that professors want to study, like albino rhinoceroses.

Just so, the idea of having a child outside of marriage was considered highly shameful in 1972. Get a girl pregnant, and you did the “honorable thing”; you married her so the child would not be illegitimate and so she wouldn’t have to raise the child without a father.

Now, many women intentionally have children while not only single but intending to raise the child as a single mother. The stigma of illegitimacy is not only gone, but delaying sex until marriage is considered odd. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

N. T. Wright’s The Day the Revolution Began, Romans Reconsidered, Part 66C (Atonement Theories)

dayrevolutionbegan

N. T. “Tom” Wright has just released another paradigm-shifting book suggesting a new, more scriptural way of understanding the atonement, The Day the Revolution Began: Reconsidering the Meaning of Jesus’s Crucifixion. Wright delves deeply into how the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus accomplish our salvation.

The heaping up of Sin

We just covered this as the theory is largely supported by passages in Rom 7 and 8. Wright points out that Paul is actually building on this chapter 5 passage —

(Rom. 5:20-21 ESV)  20 Now the law [Torah] came in [order] to increase the trespass, but where sin increased, grace abounded all the more,  21 so that, as sin reigned in death, grace also might reign through righteousness leading to eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.

Wright points out that Paul logic in this verse is not simply that this happened. He emphasizes the “so that” in v. 21 and “in order to” in v. 20, both translating the Greek hina, meaning “in order that” or “so that.” That is, not only did the Torah increase sin, but one purpose of the Torah was to increase sin  or accountable sin. That is, the more I know of God’s will, the more accountable I am for having violated it. I can no longer plead ignorance of the Law. Continue reading

Posted in Atonement, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, Romans, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

40 Years of Church Trends: Introduction, Part 1

The next few posts will be based on an article by Philip Jenkins “12 Trends That Shaped U.S. Religion Since the ’70s.”

Jenkins is the Distinguished Professor of History at Baylor University and Co-Director for Baylor’s Program on Historical Studies of Religion in the Institute for Studies of Religion. He’s the author of several significant books on church history, including one of my favorites, The Lost History of Christianity: The Thousand-Year Golden Age of the Church in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia–and How It Died.

Jenkins lists 12 trends that have impacted American Christianity since the 1970s. You should read his article and then come back here for my own thoughts in more Church of Christ terms and to discuss. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

N. T. Wright’s The Day the Revolution Began, Romans Reconsidered, Part 66B (Atonement Theories)

dayrevolutionbegan

N. T. “Tom” Wright has just released another paradigm-shifting book suggesting a new, more scriptural way of understanding the atonement, The Day the Revolution Began: Reconsidering the Meaning of Jesus’s Crucifixion. Wright delves deeply into how the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus accomplish our salvation.

The Passover

What Wright does notice is that the covenant with Abraham speaks of a future enslavement and freedom from slavery to be given by God. The covenant anticipates the exodus.

Wright often argues, with some considerable support, that Rom 6-8 recapitulates the exodus. The baptism discussion early in chapter 6 reminds us of the path out of slavery through the Red Sea (which is made explicit in 1 Cor 10). The transition from slavery to Sin and Death speaks of the escape from Egyptian slavery to the new covenant with God made at Mt. Sinai. Paul’s description of how we all struggle to obey is the story of Israel in the wilderness, having its faith tested and often failing.

The presence of God in each Christian through the indwelling Spirit recalls God leading the Israelites through the wilderness by his very presence in a column of smoke and fire. The discussion of the renewed, redeemed Creation parallels the Promised Land inheritance. Our need for the Spirit to pray for us as mediator parallels Moses’ many intercessions for the Israelites before God. The conquest of all Christ’s enemies at the end of chapter 8 parallels God’s promises to Israel to defeat her enemies and give her peace in the land. Continue reading

Posted in Atonement, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began, Romans, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Baptism Rates by State

These stats were posted at Thom Rainer’s blog.

Montana: 14.9 members for 1 baptism ratio
New York: 15.4 members for 1 baptism ratio
New England: 15.5 members for 1 baptism ratio
Dakota: 15.7 members for 1 baptism ratio
Iowa: 15.7 members for 1 baptism ratio
Pennsylvania-South Jersey: 16.9 members for 1 baptism ratio

Alabama: 59.2 members for 1 baptism ratio
North Carolina: 59.3 members for 1 baptism ratio
Texas: 65.2 members for 1 baptism ratio

I’ve not been able to source these stats other than in Thom’s blog, and he’s quoting an unnamed source, but he’s enough of an expert in his own right that these are surely correct. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 8 Comments