A 13-chapter book on whether baptism is essential to our salvation. Being a lawyer, I argue both sides. I then try to reach a conclusion. Born of Water. I’ve never felt that either side gave due respect to the other, and as a result, both sides have only argued their case at a very superficial level. This goes deeper than the usual polemics.
Subscribe to RSS feeds
Search
Categories
- Index (4,154)
- Adult Bible Classes (703)
- 1 Corinthians (109)
- 1 John (19)
- 1 Kings (1)
- 1 Samuel (12)
- 2 Samuel (11)
- Acts (46)
- Amazing Grace (69)
- Apologetics (52)
- Blue Parakeet (29)
- Creation 2.0 (36)
- Faith Lessons by Ray Vander Laan (51)
- Galatians (35)
- John (140)
- Luke (2)
- Psalms (1)
- Revelation (16)
- Sermon on the Mount (42)
- The Story (36)
- Bible Study Resources (39)
- Blogging (7)
- Book Reviews (349)
- Church Refugees (11)
- Covenant: God's Purpose, God's Plan (7)
- Gordon Wenham’s Story as Torah: Reading the Old Testament Narrative Ethically (7)
- Honor & Shame, by Roland Muller (3)
- How God Became King (3)
- John Nugent’s Endangered Gospel (9)
- Kingdom Conspiracy by Scot McKnight (21)
- Misreading Scriptures with Western Eyes (14)
- Muscle & Shovel, by Michael Shank (32)
- N. T. Wright's After You Believe (5)
- N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began (108)
- Naked Gospel, The (5)
- NT Wright's Surprised by Scripture (1)
- Paul and the Faithfulness of God (22)
- Sitting at the Feet of the Rabbi Jesus (3)
- The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24)
- The Case for the Psalms, by N. T. Wright (4)
- The Death of the Messiah and the Birth of the New Covenant, by Michael J. Gorman (7)
- To Change the World (17)
- Vines: God and the Gay Christian (6)
- Christian Disciplines (27)
- Christian Evidences/Apologetics (62)
- Archaeology (7)
- Scientific Creationism (17)
- Church & Politics (50)
- Church Finances and Business (44)
- Taxes (13)
- Church of Christ Doctrinal Issues (647)
- Age of Accountability (17)
- Assembly 2.0 (13)
- Christmas (7)
- Church of Christ Deism (16)
- Congregational Autonomy and Mergers (22)
- Denominationalism (2)
- Discipline (6)
- Divorce and Remarriage (72)
- Ecclesiology (24)
- Church 2.0 (22)
- Communion (2)
- Deacons (5)
- Fork in the Road (115)
- Instrumental Music (129)
- Real Restoration (52)
- Real Worship (32)
- Renewing Our Worship (52)
- Role of Women (91)
- Sacramentalism (12)
- What Must be Preserved of the Churches of Christ? (25)
- Church Plants and Foreign Missions (56)
- Church Trends (67)
- Churches of Christ (246)
- Commenting (13)
- Communion Meditations (42)
- Counseling (1)
- Evangelism (1)
- Grace (206)
- Amazing Grace (103)
- Facing Our Failure (3)
- Faith That Works (24)
- GraceConversation.com (15)
- Hermeneutics (207)
- Holy Spirit and Providence (124)
- Jewish Roots of Christianity (6)
- Leadership (491)
- Adult Bible Classes (9)
- Church Growth (104)
- Direct Hit (6)
- Megachurches (16)
- Replanting a Church (28)
- What's Wrong with How We Do Church (12)
- Church Ministries (29)
- Small Groups (7)
- Spiritual Formation (7)
- Church Refugees (11)
- Deacons (12)
- Elders (129)
- Advice to a New Elder (42)
- Bad Elders (9)
- Good to Great (3)
- I Sold My Soul on eBay (7)
- Leading a Small Church (3)
- Leading Change (31)
- Litigation Between Brothers (2)
- Ministers (31)
- Multi-generational/Orange Ministry (15)
- Multisite Churches (1)
- Organizing Your Church (7)
- Overseeing the Moderate Church (7)
- Preacher Searches (10)
- Preaching (4)
- Racial Diversity in Church (10)
- Sexual Ethics (17)
- Teams (2)
- The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24)
- The Pain of Disappointment (15)
- Vision (1)
- Worship/Assembly Planning (8)
- Missional Christianity (129)
- Everything Must Change (4)
- Ministry Ideas (21)
- Radical (8)
- Resident Aliens (8)
- Simply Missional (11)
- New Wineskins Magazine (26)
- Parenting (2)
- Race (1)
- Restoration Movement (55)
- Sacraments (210)
- Baptism (180)
- Lord's Supper (34)
- Sexuality (119)
- Technology (1)
- Textual studies (591)
- 1 Corinthians (108)
- 1 John (19)
- 1 Kings (1)
- 1 Samuel (13)
- 1 Thessalonians (30)
- 2 Samuel (12)
- 2 Thessalonians (18)
- Acts (46)
- Colossians (13)
- Ephesians (18)
- Galatians (40)
- Hebrews (1)
- Luke (10)
- Philemon (2)
- Revelation (62)
- Romans (163)
- Sermon on the Mount (42)
- Theology (585)
- Afterlife, The (117)
- Atonement (54)
- Available Light (46)
- Calvinism (107)
- Election (60)
- God Is Not Fair (1)
- Neo-Calvinism (8)
- Perseverance (12)
- Searching for a Third Way (21)
- The Pope, the Salvation of the Jews and Calvinism (16)
- Election (60)
- Christology (1)
- Connection of Church with Israel (74)
- Cruciform God (17)
- Gospel, What Is the? (47)
- Inerrancy and the Canon (14)
- Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (6)
- New Perspective (19)
- Pacifism (29)
- Soteriology (103)
- Salvation 2.0 (78)
- The Salvation of the Christians (9)
- The Salvation of the Jews (16)
- Universalism (11)
- Story theory (10)
- Theodicy (How God can allow bad things to happen) (7)
- Truth, What Is? (5)
- What Is Sin? (8)
- Thought Questions (83)
- Youth Ministry (10)
- Adult Bible Classes (703)
- Uncategorized (5,140)
- Index (4,154)
Recent Comments
- Guy Diffenbaugh on Site Rules
- StavinChain on Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Larry Cheek on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Larry Cheek on CENI: Binding Examples
- Michael on Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Dwight on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Stephen Youngblood on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Monty on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Larry Cheek on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Mark on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Larry Cheek on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- David on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight Haas on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Dwight Haas on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- David on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- Larry Cheek on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
Top Posts & Pages
- Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Ray Vander Laan's "Follow the Rabbi" lectures
- Acts 2: Were the Apostles Baptized in Water? Part 1
- Progressive Church of Christ Blogs, E-Zines, Writings and Groups
- Communion Meditation: God's Great Banquet
- U.S. Income and Employment Taxes for Missionaries (corrected and expanded)
- The Story: The Tabernacle, Worship, and the Christian, Part 1 (Living Sacrifices)
- The Story: Ruth the Moabite, Part 3 (The Genealogy and Conclusions)
- 1 Corinthians 6:9-11 ("the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God")
- More Missionaries and Taxes Regarding Housing
Re: "Born of Water". You state regarding the validity of cases made for and against the necessity of baptism down through the history of the Church that due to both sides having argued their cases only "at a very superficial level" Jay Guin will finally, after 2,000 years of intellectual darkness, bestow upon the world the definitive answer to this important question. You even plan to do so at great depth – something you have castigated others for doing in the name and cause of biblical scholarship. Evidently there is a great deal of that taught in law school and the only type that is applicable to the scriptures. However, since the Holy Spirit literally tells you specifically what to say and do, it is only logical that all of your thoughts and actions would be infallible. It could not be otherwise.
This present comment is made almost 4 years after the post and comment #1 by Nichols. Four years – well, are we enlightened yet?
Comments such as the one of 03/05/2007 offer no help in reversing "2,000 years of intellectual darkness." Rather, it fits right in.
Iron may sharpen iron; plastic doesn't.
That's about the nicest way I know how to say it.