New Wineskins: Three More Articles Posted, The Rest of the Interview with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman and Another Article by Me

WineskinsbannerThe first nine articles in the New Wineskins series on instrumental music have now been posted —

The complete list is —

Introduction — The Instrumental Music Issue, by Jay Guin

On God’s Salvation, Galatians, and the Instrument, by Jay Guin

“Thy Kingdom Come” and the Instrument, by Jay Guin

The Early Church on Christian Music, by Danny Corbitt

Reconsidering Ephesians 5:19, by Clyde Symonette

Psallo: Lost in the Translation, by Danny Corbitt

Reflective or Regulative, by Al Maxey

An Afternoon with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman, Part 1

An Afternoon with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman, Part 2

An Afternoon with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman, Part 3

An Afternoon with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman, Part 4

Reflections on My Interview with Rick Atchley and Chris Seidman, by Jay Guin

David’s Psalms in the New Testament Church, by Clyde Symonnette

Beyond the Pitch Pipe, by Ryan Christian

And so, In Conclusion, by Jay Guin

Please make a point of helping to spread the word about this series — among all factions of the Churches of Christ. These articles won’t do much good unless they’re widely read. Post notes in appropriate forums and on your own blogs and otherwise help be sure these articles are noticed. As the next few posts will show, this won’t be just a rehash of the old canned arguments.

Posted in Instrumental Music, New Wineskins Magazine, Uncategorized | 2 Comments

New Wineskins: A Thought Experiment on Sola Scriptura and the Historical Argument, Part 1

WineskinsbannerThe tradition of the apostles

Readers have argued that there’s a position in between the Protestant sola scriptura (the scriptures only, as argued by the Reformation leaders) and the Catholic/Orthodox view that the teachings of early church leaders and church councils reflect the will of the Holy Spirit and thus carry the same weight as scripture.

They argue that the early church had the benefit of, not only the scriptures, but also the traditions — the oral teachings of the apostles. Now, in traditional Church of Christ thought, the scriptures are the only true authority, but the historical record gives evidence of what the scriptures truly mean. Thus, we supplement the scriptures with Tertullian and Irenaeus when it suits us. Not that they have any authority in themselves but they bear witness to a recollection of apostolic teaching.

The implicit — and rarely stated — assumption is that there was some body of apostolic teaching transmitted orally that supplements and completes the New Testament. Therefore, it’s hardly surprising that we’re now hearing voices that make this implicit assumption explicit — asserting that uninspired writings of the early church fathers must be studied and interpreted in order to understand the New Testament correctly. It’s not that these uninspired sources are themselves inspired, but that these men had access to an oral tradition now lost and recoverable only through diligent study of uninspired writings. Continue reading

Posted in Instrumental Music, New Wineskins Magazine, Uncategorized | 55 Comments

Re Sabbatical

So I went nearly a week without writing anything at all. Travel, reading, funeral, chuch work, work work, etc., etc. It was easy. Too much other stuff to do. Too worn out. Too emotionally drained.

But things got better (notwithstanding Alabama’s loss to LSU). Things are settling down, and these posts keep popping into my head. But I find it’s kind of nice to be posting every other day rather than every day. I enjoy the slower pace, but it bothers me. You see, I wrote a post regarding a series of comments on sola scriptura, and it has lots of quoted material. I thought I should break it up into three posts, for the sake of size and all. But that means it’ll be the only thing posted for 6 whole days! And I’m afraid that gives greater prominence to the article than it really deserves. In former times, I’d have posted over three days and thrown in some lessons on Ephesians for good measure!

And I really have to catch up my Ephesians posts, because I’m teaching Ephesians and really need to be prepared. I’m about to delve into chapter 5 in class, and preparation will really matter on that chapter!

So I’m not sure I can keep up the slower pace. But I think I really ought to try. (Maybe I should re-run posts from the past in the off days? I got a million of ’em …!)

All of which is to say I’ve not had a vision or any particularly clear sense of direction, other than the fact that I find myself drawn inexorably toward the keyboard once again, and my fingers keep typing when I get there. God doesn’t always work on my time schedule. He can be quite annoying that way, you know. But I would definitely prefer to be typing away while awaiting further guidance, if further guidance there is to be. And maybe it’s enough to know that I’m not out of ideas, the fingers still insist on typing, and I still enjoy this. At a slower pace. For now.

Posted in Uncategorized | 9 Comments

The Fork in the Road: The Man or the Plan, Part 15 (Kingdom and Community, Part 3)

N. T. Wright on Unity

Thanks to Bobby Valentine for finding this!

PS — This is the last post until I return from Sabbatical.

Posted in Fork in the Road, Uncategorized | 2 Comments

On Mourning the Demise of Our National Championship Hopes

Alabama’s football team lost to LSU yesterday. And we lost to South Carolina a few weeks ago — the same South Carolina Gamecocks who just laid an egg against Arkansas. There is no consolation. We have zero chance at a national, conference, or divisional championship. The best we can hope for is to win the state championship — by beating Auburn

And we hate Auburn. The thought of losing to Auburn and seeing them in the national championship game is unbearable to the typical Alabama fan, you know. I know it’s not healthy to feel that way. I know that Auburn isn’t evil or the incarnation of Satan. I know that. But it’s hard to shake a lifetime of tradition and conditioning. You see, the natural order of things is that Alabama wins national championships — and Auburn does not. And I really don’t want my paradigm shifted. I like my paradigm.

But Auburn gets to be in the BCS championship game if they just beat Georgia, Alabama, and the winner of the SEC eastern division — a division all six teams are trying desperately to lose. From here, Auburn’s path to national championship glory looks very easy. We look terrible. Auburn looks unstoppable.

And Oregon looks pretty good — amazing really — but that’s against Pac 10, West Coast competition. I think Auburn beats them by two touchdowns. Alabama, meanwhile, will miss the Sugar Bowl, too (LSU is a shoe in), playing in some forgettable bowl in Florida. I forget its name and don’t care to look it up.

I’m inconsolable. And, yes, I have a son at Auburn. And, no, that doesn’t make it any easier. Now I have to live with whole thing. Life has lost all meaning. There is no hope. There is no balm in Tampa or wherever we wind up playing. Oh, the pain of dashed high expectations!

You know, life was better when we were lousy and struggling to get better. Then any victory was wonderful and the losses were expected and didn’t hurt so much. Watching the team get better and occasionally win unexpectedly was great, great fun! But, oh, the misery of losing unexpectedly!

Thank goodness, basketball season is here! We were lousy last year. Winning just 50% of our games would be ecstasy! Going to the NCAAs would be beyond our wildest dreams! Oh, the bliss of low expectations. Maybe God really does bless those who mourn. Maybe God really does cause the last to be first. Maybe you need the lousy years to appreciate the good ones. But it’s hard being philosophical when Auburn is about waltz into a national championship.


Posted in Uncategorized | 8 Comments

Minister Jobs

I’ve just added a new page called Ministers Looking for Churches / Churches Looking for Ministers, which can also be found under the “Jobs and Blogs” link at the top of the page or via the Page listing on the left of the screen. I hope it helps churches and ministers find each other.

(The listing of progressive Church of Christ blogs is also found under “Jobs and Blogs” now.)

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

Reader Looking for a Church in Orlando

A reader has asked for a recommendation for a non-legalistic congregation in Orlando, Florida. While I’m very familiar with DisneyWorld (my wife is an addict and refuses all interventions), I’m not familiar with the congregations in the area. Any suggestions?

Posted in Uncategorized | 6 Comments

The Fork in the Road: The Man or the Plan, Part 14 (Kingdom and Community, Part 2)

The prophets

Isaiah prophesied before the time of Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon. While Nebuchadnezzar launched campaigns against Jerusalem, Jeremiah prophesied in Jerusalem, and Ezekiel prophesied in Babylon, among the earlier captives to be taken there. Later Daniel prophesied in Babylon, and Zecharian prophesied after a remnant of the Jews returned to Jerusalem under Ezra and Nehemiah.

(Isa 9:6-7 ESV) 6 For to us a child is born, to us a son is given; and the government shall be upon his shoulder, and his name shall be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace. 7 Of the increase of his government and of peace there will be no end, on the throne of David and over his kingdom, to establish it and to uphold it with justice and with righteousness from this time forth and forevermore. The zeal of the LORD of hosts will do this. Continue reading

Posted in Fork in the Road, Uncategorized | 4 Comments

The Fork in the Road: The Man or the Plan, Part 13 (Kingdom and Community, Part 1)

(Wednesday night class, October 27, 2010)

Introduction

My wife and I are big Agatha Christie fans. We love mysteries. Last Christmas, I bought her all the missing volumes for my wife’s collection — and I learned that many of the books are out of print. I had to buy them from used book dealers.

And it occurred to me — and although I’m not like this — I know lots of people who turn to the last couple of chapters to read them first. They just especially enjoy knowing how things turn out. And all mystery readers enjoy the final chapters the most. We like seeing the mystery revealed.

So I’m trying to raise money to buy the publication rights for these books. And I figure I’ll save a lot of money by printing just the last three chapters of each book — because those are the fun chapters, the ones where you found out how it ends, who did it. Those are where the mystery is revealed — so what’s the point of spending money on the first 10 chapters or so, all of which are superseded by the exciting conclusion? I’ll make a fortune!!

And this is, of course, a profoundly stupid idea. After all, the fun is really in seeing how it all unfolds. There’s no point in knowing that the butler did it unless you know what he did and know how hard it was for the detective to figure it out. You can’t be amazed at his brilliance unless you follow the story with him, get fooled by the red herrings and false trails. You have to experience the story to appreciate the ending. Even those who cheat and skip to the end do so intending to read the whole thing. No one buys just the last few chapters.

Except Christians. Christians actually buy Bible’s with the entire Old Testament — except for the Psalms — excised, because they never need the Old Testament. To them, it’s not even part of the story. It’s just children’s stories and a few Messianic prophecies. And this is one reason why they misunderstand the New Testament. You don’t know who the butler is or what he did unless you start at the beginning. Continue reading

Posted in Fork in the Road, Uncategorized | 3 Comments

The Fork in the Road: The Man or the Plan, Part 12 (Summary So Far)

We’ve been talking about the nature of our faith. Why does Paul focus on faith and love as the essence of Christianity — even saying that nothing else counts for anything?

(Gal 5:6 ESV) 6 For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision counts for anything, but only faith working through love.

“Only” means only. Only faith (in Jesus) and love (for our neighbors) count in God’s eyes.

This statement is so different from how we in the Churches of Christ ordinarily think of our salvation that we just ignore it. We argue that “works” is the Law of Moses, so lots of things count other than faith and love. But that’s plainly not what Paul said. He said “only.”

Here the gopher wood argument actually applies. Noah made the ark of gopher wood, not gopher wood plus whatever else tradition told him. “Only” means only. Continue reading

Posted in Fork in the Road, Uncategorized | 37 Comments