To: [email protected]
Subject: Lectureship Question for Spring church of Christ
Brothers in Christ,
I’ve been deeply disappointed by the recent Profiles in Apostasy lectures and believe they reflect a seriously false understanding of the scriptures that is doing great harm to the Churches of Christ.
I particularly disagree with the implicit premise that any doctrinal error necessarily damns. I mean, you’ve even declared Phil Sanders apostate over his views on the Holy Spirit, even though for my entire life this has not been considered a salvation issue in the Churches of Christ. It seems that you’ve greatly expanded the category of salvation issues.
I’m sure you have your reasons for disagreeing with my understanding of the scriptures, and I think those reasons need to be considered in a forum where both sides can be heard by the largest possible audience. Therefore, I’d like to invite you to a dialogue regarding when a Christian becomes at apostate at my website, . This site is among the most popular in the Churches of Christ, having received over 50,000 page views in January.
I would offer you unfettered access to my readership to explain how you decide what issues are apostasy issues, and I’d offer a format that allows you to post and respond as you have opportunity — as we all have other commitments.
Your posts will receive the widest publicity within the Churches, as I have readers from all segments — one cup, no Sunday school, ICOC, non-institutional, conservative, progressive, and even the independent Christian Churches.
Please consider this invitation prayerfully. Are you willing to explain and defend the scriptural basis on which you damn so many leaders within the Churches of Christ in a fair and open forum?
Jay Guin
Tuscaloosa, AL
PS — This email is being posted at my site as open letter