Searching for The Third Way: Introduction

three It gets so tiresome, you know, arguing about the Bible. And the worst of it is that you rarely actually convince anyone. They have their verses. You have your verses. And you just talk past each other, knowing that your verses represent perfect saving truth and their verses are taken just so badly out of context and misunderstood. Of course, the person you’re arguing with feels exactly the same way … but that’s okay. He’s deluded.

But that other person … the deluded one, you know … is actually quite bright and has studied the Bible very diligently. And yet he just … won’t … listen. And it’s so … very … frustrating!

Continue reading

Posted in Searching for a Third Way, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Searching for The Third Way: Introduction

Leading Change: On Being a “Change Agent” and a “Liberal”

change.jpgI’m going to post a series of articles on how to help your church change. As a lead in, we probably need to talk a little bit about the name calling that such efforts lead to.

Don’t for a minute imagine that it’s easy to lead a church into any kind of change. It’s not. And it will be harder for most than for me. I’m privileged by not depending on the Churches for my living and having been surrounded by supportive leaders for most of my adult life. It’s harder for ministers who have to support their families. And it’s much harder in congregations where the elders are the ones resisting necessary change. Continue reading

Posted in Leading Change, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Leading Change: On Being a “Change Agent” and a “Liberal”

Amazing Grace: Objections (revised, again)

grace2.jpgWe’re not through laying out a theology of grace, but this is a good time to pause and respond to the obvious objections to what’s been taught thus far.

Nadab and Abihu

Nadab and Abihu were sons of Aaron and priests when the Law of Moses was first instituted. They offered “strange fire” and God killed them.

Going back to earliest Calvinism, this passage has been used to defend the Regulative Principle, which is the idea that any thing added to the Bible’s instructions for how to worship is sin, and not just sin, but sin that damns. Continue reading

Posted in Amazing Grace, Amazing Grace, Uncategorized | Tagged | Comments Off on Amazing Grace: Objections (revised, again)

A Plea to Reconsider: On How Hard Humility Is, the Conclusion of it All

angelharp1.jpg(1 Pet 5:5b-6) All of you, clothe yourselves with humility toward one another, because, “God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble.” 6 Humble yourselves, therefore, under God’s mighty hand, that he may lift you up in due time.

I’m convinced that part of the psychology that drives many of us within the Churches of Christ toward legalism is the pleasure of feeling smarter than the church down the road. I don’t mean to imply any insincerity — far from it. Nor do I think this feeling of superiority is conscious. No, it’s deeply buried in our psyches, and this is one reason it’s so very hard to root out. Continue reading

Posted in Instrumental Music, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Plea to Reconsider: On How Hard Humility Is, the Conclusion of it All

January’s top posts

star.jpgWell, January is over — in Greenwich, England, and WordPress keeps their stats on Greenwich time, so it’s time for the month-end summation.

January had over 10,000 views, compared to December’s previous record of over 6,300! I’m really surprised to have had a 60% increase in one month. I’m not really sure what’s driving the growth, but I’m pleased that someone else finds this stuff interesting.

Here are the top posts for January.

Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Comments Off on January’s top posts

A Plea to Reconsider: Abusing Restoration Movement History

angelharp1.jpgMiller’s concluding paragraph begins,

Over a century ago, many churches of Christ were swept into what was then called “the digression.” The use of musical instruments in worship was one of the divisive issues that caused the breach. History is now repeating itself.

This is entirely true. The a cappella Churches of Christ separated itself from the larger remaining parts of the Restoration Movement over, among other things, the instrument.

It’s important to know and learn from our history. But Miller learned the wrong lesson. You see, the list of “divisive issues” that we split over is much longer than just the fight over the instrument — and we should learn entirely different lessons from why we split. Continue reading

Posted in Instrumental Music, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Plea to Reconsider: Abusing Restoration Movement History

Amazing Grace: Now that We’re Saved (reflections on the previous 3 lessons), expanded

 [I had a student ask for some material from lessons taught years ago, and so I’ve added the chart and text beneath it. Of course, we’re really just getting going. There are more charts to come. I’ve also added an example from a recent email condemning a Church of Christ for approving instruments. It’s the perfect example for the point I was trying to make.]

grace2.jpgThis is not easy stuff. Well, it’s only really hard because so many of us have been taught error, and the error is so familiar that we struggle to integrate these new truths into our understanding. Therefore, we need to take some time to kick these ideas around a bit to be sure we’ve really absorbed what’s being said.

The two-kinds-of-falling-away mistake

Some teach two levels of falling away–a temporary, easily fixed falling away where you go forward, confess your sins, and receive forgiveness and a permanent, impossible to fix falling away described in Hebrews. Continue reading

Posted in Amazing Grace, Amazing Grace, Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment

A Plea to Reconsider: A Return to Creeds?

angelharp1.jpgMiller’s conclusion focuses on the articles of incorporation of the Richland Hills Church of Christ. You see, as is true of many Churches of Christ, the original articles specified that the church may never use “mechanical” instruments of worship and must take the Lord’s Supper every Sunday.

Moreover, the articles specified that only men who agreed with the founders on instrumental music may be ordained elders. The articles actually attempted to add conditions beyond those stipulated in God’s word!

The elders amended the articles to remove these specific rules. Miller is outraged.

But Miller forgets his principles. After all, the articles of incorporation were nothing but a creed — which I thought we in the Churches of Christ long ago rejected.

And don’t we believe that the elders have the spiritual leadership of the congregation — not a legal document? Do we really believe that elders should be bound by charters written decades ago by men long dead? Is that the Biblical pattern of church governance? Continue reading

Posted in Instrumental Music, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Plea to Reconsider: A Return to Creeds?

Amazing Grace: Now that We’re Saved (the Hebrews lesson), expanded

[In doing class preparation, I realized this lesson would likely take only 45 of the 55 minutes we now have. And so I added about 30 minutes worth of new material.]

grace2.jpgA very long time ago, when I was a teenager, I remember showing up for Sunday school class with the other teens. One of the deacons entered the class and said, “Well, I tried to run, but the elders caught me and insisted that I teach this class. So what do you want to study? I’ll teach any book of the Bible that you’re interested in–except Romans and Hebrews.” He winced, to make his point. “I don’t understand anything those books are saying! If you want to study those, you’ll have to get a better teacher than me!”

In my experience, we in the Churches of Christ don’t spend much time in Hebrews. I’m glad that Romans has come back into fashion. It’s the book we usually use to teach lessons on grace. It’s a thorough grounding but raises a whole bunch of really difficult issues.

On the other hand, I find Hebrews relatively straightforward. Now, I didn’t use to. In fact, it used to be completely opaque. I later learned that I couldn’t understand it because I was reading it with false assumptions–lots of false assumptions. You see, Hebrews is about as un-traditional-Church of Christ as any New Testament book can be. I’ll explain why. Continue reading

Posted in Amazing Grace, Amazing Grace, Uncategorized | Tagged | Comments Off on Amazing Grace: Now that We’re Saved (the Hebrews lesson), expanded

A Plea to Reconsider: What’s Not Religious?

angelharp1.jpgOn page 89, Miller begins to set up the classic “gopher wood” argument —

But does that mean that we must have authority for everything we do in religion? Everything? What about the many things we do that the Bible does not mention? For example, where is our authority for church buildings, pews, lighting, carpet, television programs, songbooks, and communion trays?

Did you notice it? The subtle change in argument? Miller is playing three-card Monte. While you’re not watching, he hides what’s really going on. Continue reading

Posted in Instrumental Music, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Plea to Reconsider: What’s Not Religious?